Evidence for an Extended Scattered Disk?

Orbit Determination of 2000 CR105

2000 CR105 is a transneptunain object (in our Solar System's Kuiper Belt beyond Neptune), discovered in Febuary 2000 during a Kuiper Belt survey by a team at Lowell Observatory. We tracked the object in March 2000 from the Canada-France-Hawaii telescope and showed that the object's orbit was larger than any other known Kuiper Belt object, and in particular the fact that it's pericenter was farther from Neptune than any other highly-eccentric object. Since then we have continued to follow the object and have proven that its orbit is only weakly affected by the giant planets. A paper has been submitted to the journal Icarus describing the implications of this fact.
Evidence for an extended scattered disk
B. Gladman, M. Holman, T. Grav, J. Kavelaars, P. Nicholson, K. Aksnes, and J-M. Petit.

The paper has been accepted by Icaurs, and is also available via WWW download as
UNCOMPRESSED POSTSCRIPT (3.8 Mb), at http://www.obs-nice.fr/gladman/Extended.ps
G-ZIPPED POSTSCRIPT (0.52 Mb), at http://www.obs-nice.fr/gladman/Extgz.ps.gz


JPG images of 2000 CR105 in Normal black and white and Negative formats.


This figure compares the orbits of the other scattered disk objects
with that we have estimated for 2000 CR105.

This figure shows the orbits of all the known scattered disk objects (SDOs)
as well as the much larger orbit of 2000 CR105 (in red).
The SDOs are objects which are on large looping orbits; the most developed
theories for the creation of the scattered disk produce these orbits by
gravitational scattering due to Neptune, which hurls them out to external
orbits which take hundreds of year to circulate around the Sun.
Numerical calculations have shown that some of the objects can rest in
this state for the 4.5-billion year lifetime of the Solar System.
The first recognized SDO was 1996 TL66, discovered by Luu et al. in 1996
(reprint in pdf format available on the www).
About two dozen such SDOs are now known, many of them have been discovered
and tracked by C. Trujillo et al.

The figure shows that 2000 CR105 journeys far from the Sun, several times
further than the other SDOs.
There are long-period comets that journey much farther away towards the
Oort cloud.
The interesting facet of CR105's orbit is NOT its large size, but rather
the fact that its perihelion (distance of closest approach to the Sun) is
larger than any other known Solar System object.

This figure shows a dot at the perihelion position of each of the SDOs
plotted in the previous diagram, marking the point of closest solar approach.
Only the orbit of 2000 CR105 is shown, and is dotted when the orbit is below
the plane of the other planets and solid when above (2000 CR105's orbit is
inclined about 20 degrees with respect to the plane of the solar system).

The circle shows the orbit of Neptune, for reference. The straight solid
line is the `line of nodes' of CR105, showing where its orbit intersects
the plane of the planets.

CR105 is currently past it's line of nodes and heading out farther into
deep space to the top left of this plot.

It is striking that this roughly 400-km object would be visible, even
to the most powerful telescopes, for only a tiny fraction of its orbital
period, while it is in the tiny portion near pericenter of its more than
3000-year orbital journey.

Because the perihelia of the SDOs are near Neptune, it is thought
that they are likely to be objects that in the ancient past had a close
pass to Neptune and the planet's gravity `sling-shotted' them out onto large
orbits. Dynamical computer simulations by Hal Levison and Martin Duncan
show in detail how the orbits of this population are distributed.
However, these simulations do NOT produce orbits with PERIHELIA as far
away as 2000 CR105 (although orbits as LARGE do occur).
Simply put, this is because the objects that are scattered out from Neptune by close
encounters are `close' to the planet at the instant of scattering.
The object will then return to that point after one orbit and only continual
long-term `wandering' of the perihelion due to encounters that are not
as close can allow the perihelion to drift away from Neptune.

The numerical simulations seem to show that it is possible for perihelia to
eventually reach distances as far away as 40 AU. However, CR105's perihelion
if 4.3 AU farther out than that (almost the distance from the Sun to Jupiter!)
Therefore, the simulations do not seem to produce objects like this, and we
believe that for the moment 2000 CR105 should NOT be classed as an SDO.

In the preprint (available above) we discuss various scenarios which could
have produced this fascinating object.

Technical information

All known astrometry of 2000 CR105 (MPC format, last update 31 Mar/2001)

Page maintained by:
Brett Gladman 
Observatoire de la Cote d'Azur
URL: http://www.obs-nice.fr/gladman

OCA logo CNRS logo